Pages:6 (1683 words)
On Wearing School Uniforms
One of the biggest problems that teens face in school is the problem of peer pressure. As Bandura (2018) notes, the pressure to adapt one’s behavior in order to fit in or stand out comes from media, peers and groups—and in a school, peers are the biggest factor. One way to alleviate that pressure is to create an environment in which everyone fits in ipso facto—and that can easily be achieved by obliging all students to wear a school uniform. One is used to seeing students of private schools wear uniforms, but in public schools this idea is typically shunned. There are good arguments to be made, however, for uniforms to be mandated by public schools. First off, research has shown that school uniforms actually promote good conduct among students and more formal adherence to the rules and regulations of the school. Second, parents and teachers support the idea. Third, it is a way to level the playing field and keep teens from thinking about how they should look: focus can be on books instead of on looks. Fourth, uniforms can instill greater confidence in students by helping to create an environment in which self-esteem and self-actualization can be achieved. While there is no real consensus among researchers as to what the empirical justification for school uniforms is, this paper will argue that school uniforms are simply a common sense way to help reduce peer pressure in public schools and get young students focused on believing in themselves, in each other, and in their school. Thus, this paper will show that school uniforms can promote positive self-esteem and self-belief in elementary school age children.
The good conduct basis for this argument comes from a study by Stanley (1996) on the Long Beach Unified School District, which in 1994 made uniforms mandatory for all K-8 students. Long Beach was the first public school district in the nation to mandate uniforms, and Stanley (1996) conducted a two-year study of the students of the school district from 1993 to 1995 to see if there was any correlation between the implementation of the uniform policy and alterations in student behavior. Stanley (1996) found that indeed there was a correlation: significant improvement in the conduct of the district’s nearly 100,000 students was demonstrated following the mandatory adoption of school uniforms. Suspension rates declined 28% in the elementary schools and 36% in the middle schools; fights decreased by 51% in grades K-8, and assault and battery incidents decreased 34% in the elementary and middle schools (Stanley, 1996). In short, a significant correlation between uniform-wearing in public schools and improved student conduct was evident.
The statistically significant findings of Stanley’s (1996) study are convincing in their own right—but parents and teachers bring another perspective to the argument that shows how simply from a common sense perspective adopting school uniforms in public schools can be beneficial. For example, the National Association of Elementary School Principals (NAESP) and uniform manufacturer Lands’ End surveyed school leaders across the nation and found that the overwhelming majority of them believe…
…difficult it can be to control for all variables or to test a hypothesis such as this one. Different researchers may approach the issue with their own biases, which they are unable to filter or bracket out. Or their methodologies may differ significantly, leading to differences in samples and sample sizes. The fact is that there has been no gold standard study conducted to see if there is any statistically significant difference in achievement and self-esteem between students who do not wear uniforms and students who do. The reason for this is that it is essentially impossible to control for all the variables that might impact such a study. Uniforms, one must admit, are but one part of the equation. Families, parents, neighborhoods, media—all these elements also play a part, as Bandura (2018) observes in his study on what influences behavior.
In conclusion, there is much evidence that shows how much of an impact school uniforms can have on student achievement and self-esteem. The Long Beach study, for example, showed how influential uniforms can be. Parents and teachers have all argued that uniforms make it so much easier for students to focus on what matters—their studies. Common sense suggests that when students where uniforms they are more likely to feel accepted and part of a whole rather than as rejects or outsiders who must try to find a way to fit in. All the evidence may not be in, but what has been produced signals that school uniforms help a lot more than they could possibly hurt.
Bandura, A. (2018). Toward a psychology of human agency: Pathways and reflections. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 13(2), 130-136.
Bodine, A. (2003). School uniforms, academic achievement, and uses of research. The Journal of Educational Research, 97(2), 67-71.
Caruso, P. (1996). Individuality vs. conformity: The issue behind school uniforms. NASSP Bulletin, 80(581), 83-88.
Fox, K. R., & Lindwall, M. (2014). Self-esteem and self-perceptions in sport and exercise. In Routledge Companion to Sport and Exercise Psychology (pp. 58-72). Routledge.
Murray, R. K. (1997). The impact of school uniforms on school climate. NASSP Bulletin, 81(593), 106-112.
NAESP. (2013). National Survey of School Leaders Reveals 2013 School Uniform Trends. Retrieved from https://www.naesp.org/national-survey-school-leaders-reveals-2013-school-uniform-trends
School connectedness: Strategies for increasing protective factors among youth. (2010). Reclaiming Children and Youth, 19(3), 20-24.
Stanley, M. S. (1996). School uniforms and safety. Education and Urban Society, 28(4), 424-435.
The researchers omitted the public sector data which had a positive correlation, and drew their conclusion from only the Catholic and private school sectors which had a negative correlation. Including the omitted data would have changed the overall conclusions. The authors warn against citing and using research that has methodological flaws. School Uniform Relation to Attendance A school uniform policy has been strongly suggested as a way to curb school violence
In the most serious examples, street gangs and high school fraternities use colors and specific styles of clothing to proclaim allegiances. On occasion, individuals are even assaulted and violently attacked on or in the vicinity of school grounds merely for wearing the wrong colored clothes (Harvard Crimson, 2008). Mandatory school uniforms would solve all three problems. The principal objection to the idea arises in connection with First Amendment concerns
School Uniforms Those against school uniforms mainly argue that they violate a student's freedom of expression and may interfere with religious clothing preferences (Kelly). However, evidence suggests that the benefits far outweigh these disadvantages. Educators, students and parents alike should view school uniforms as a good thing for a variety of reasons. Isaacson (1998) compared two middle schools in Charleston County, S.C., one with a uniform policy, the other without. The researcher
Albeit there is not direct link between improvement in students' behavior and academic performance and the use of uniforms, there had been many anecdotes to support this claim. Having students wear uniforms conjures perceptions of order, safety and security as uniforms are viewed as "concrete and visible means of restoring order to the classroom" (Anderson 3). Uniforms may also lessen incidences of violence and crime against students, as many acts
Additional arguments against school uniforms are the violation of free expression and students' rights and the stifling of student individuality (Schachter 48-49; Wilkins 22). These arguments for and against school uniforms do not have enough sway to decide the point alone. If research implied a link to academic or behavioral changes one way or the other, it is likely that such minor matters would fall in line or become only
Uniforms in School: A Benefit for Students and Educators Alike In recent years educators, administrators, government officials and even parents and community members have been divided over the issues of school uniforms. While many still violently oppose the notion of mandated uniforms in educational institutions, there is a growing population of people that support uniforms for a variety of reasons. There have been several studies of late that have examined the