Study Document

The Practice of American Public Policymaking Essay

Pages:5 (1629 words)

Sources:3

Subject:Government

Topic:Policy Implementation

Document Type:Essay

Document:#86627986


The Principles of Machiavelli in American Policy

The first chapter in The Practice of American Public Policymaking lays out what the book examines in the succeeding chapters. First, Briggs and Helms (2015) define policymaking as “the activities, actors, institutions, practices, and technologies that combine to ‘deliver the goods’ to the American people” (p. 3). Public policy is defined as “the art and science of producing results” (p. 3). Thus, the book is primarily about American public policymaking and the focus is on conception and practice, which means that both the development and the implementation of policy are covered in the following chapters. Implementation is especially important because it refers to the process of monitoring and evaluating policy. Policy and management should be part and parcel, according to the authors as “there is no policy without implementation” and there is no awareness of the success of a policy without evaluation (Briggs & Helms, 2015, p. 3). The book does not focus on analysis but rather on practice primarily—on the what rather than the why.

Technology—from TV to budgets—is discussed in order to show that public policymaking is not just about how media is used but also about how budgets are managed and how projects proceed. Briggs and Helms (2015) point out that some of the most controversial public policies—like those on privacy or abortion—are byproducts of technological breakthroughs. Institutional and historical factors are also considered, as everything in the realm of public policymaking is viewed as a work in progress. Briggs and Helms (2015) explain that actors today are much different from the actors of a hundred years ago. Because the authors use the case study method for explaining public policymaking in America, they provide the history and background on their examples to facilitate contextualization. The authors also employ the technique of policy mapping to show how the practice and art of public policymaking is conducted.

In the second chapter, the authors examine how public policymaking is conducted in the 21st century. The second chapter is essentially an overview of public policymaking research and history, and the chapter starts with a discussion of policy from the standpoint of Machiavelli, who stated that policy was about using knowledge to inform statecraft and further the ends of the state. This is an important point because it should be noted that the idea is to further the ends of the state—not the people. The state is conceived as an entity unto itself, while in America there idea behind the government is that it is supposed to be for and by the people (Mizaur, 1993). Yet here in the outset of the book on policy, the authors openly state that American public policymaking has taken its cues from the master of statecraft and of putting the interests of the state—i.e., of the prince—first and foremost. In other words, the people are there to serve the prince rather than the prince being there to serve the state. If the policy approach of Machiavelli is the basis of policymaking in the US, then the American public has been fed a canard with the idea of democracy.…

Some parts of this document are missing

Click here to view full document

…policy. Then the authors go on to state that Machiavellian politics has never taken root in America.

Yet in the very beginning, the authors stated that Machiavellian’s principles are the root of policymaking today and they also stated that American policymaking is really not much different from policymaking in other countries. Thus it cannot be said to be a national failing of character. What the authors do show is that Americans use technology to create their sense of policy. Policy is preferred over politics in America, according to the authors, but one may well wonder at this point whether the authors actually live in America because that is almost certainly not the case—especially since 2016. If anything, Americans today would rather fight over politics than talk about policy. Policy is almost a laughable word at this point because American politicians have shown themselves to be the hacks that they are. And if they are hacks then who is writing the policy? Americans may have a preference for policy, according to the authors but there is no way they are having that preference fulfilled.

Then there are the arguments such as this one—that Roosevelt’s New Deal policy became a source of confidence for Americans and their belief in the government to take care of them? Is this a revisionist history book? Most Americans were thoroughly discouraged by the New Deal and found it to be too little too late. The text goes on to show that technology changed the way Americans think about policy but at this point the authors seem…


Sample Source(s) Used

References

Briggs, S., & Helms, L. B. (2015). The practice of American public policymaking. New York: Routlege Taylor & Francis Group.

DeLeon, P., & DeLeon, L. (2002). What ever happened to policy implementation? An alternative approach. Journal of public administration research and theory, 12(4), 467-492.

Mizaur, D. G. (1993). Quality government is government of the people, by the people, for the people. Public Productivity & Management Review, 371-377.

Cite this Document

Join thousands of other students and "spark your studies."

Sign Up for FREE
Related Documents

Study Document

Public Policymaking

Pages: 4 (1318 words) Sources: 3 Subject: Health - Nursing Document: #88869657

Government Examine an issue of current relevance to Public Policymaking. As you consider topics, remember that this policy paper should contain a comprehensive assessment of the intended policy and its potential consequences. When you write your paper, you should think of yourself as a staff person who must advise a policy maker facing a problem that must be resolved in the near future. As the staff person, adopt one of the

Study Document

Public Policy-Making: Public School Funding

Pages: 15 (4206 words) Sources: 5 Subject: Teaching Document: #53478876

The trial lasted seven months and Justice Leland Degrasse rendered his decision, 719 N.Y.S.2d 475 on January 10, 2001, in favor of plaintiffs and ordered the state to ensure that all public schools provide the opportunity for a sound basic education to their students." (Hunter, 2004) Entered, as part of this decision was a "costing-out study as the threshold task in developing a new school funding system." (Hunter, 2004)

Study Document

Public Policy and Stem Public

Pages: 10 (3402 words) Sources: 6 Subject: Teaching Document: #14525860

If we can institute more policies to make STEM education within our higher education system more inclusive, we can assume that this diversity will make STEM attractive to minority students. In order for policy makers to know where to begin with minority students, they need to know what is preventing them from getting a good STEM education, what factors have contributed to minorities who are successful in this field and

Study Document

American Presidency

Pages: 8 (2692 words) Sources: 1+ Subject: Government Document: #85133924

American Presidency How Presidents can influence the policymaking process to suit their needs constitution has created the executive branch and the executive power vested in the hands of the president. In fact, the president cannot act in isolation in running the executive branch. The president depends on the executive office staff and agencies like office of management and council of economic advisors and the policy development offices like the National Security Council.

Study Document

American Government the American Governing

Pages: 3 (1244 words) Sources: 1+ Subject: Government Document: #82232346

The contact between the two groups is not always straight forward, and is often fought officially, through judicial practices, and unofficially, through dubious backstage arrangements and activities. However, there is also a legal manner through which interest groups have been given the right to influence political decisions and the laws voted upon. Lobbying is one such activity. Although lobbyists are the subject of heated debate, as many citizens consider them to

Study Document

Policy Studies the Study of Public Policy

Pages: 10 (2628 words) Sources: 1+ Subject: Government Document: #77093155

Policy Studies The study of public policy gained significant importance in the late fifties and sixties. However, policy science did not come into existence all of a sudden. It started to emerge when social scientists started researches on a wide range of sociopolitical problems. After the World War II, significant developments were made in the areas of operations research, economics and social psychology. These developments proved to be helpful in formulating

Join thousands of other students and

"spark your studies".