Studyspark Study Document

Enforcing Standards and Discipline in the United States Army Capstone Project

Pages:6 (1880 words)

Sources:3

Subject:Government

Topic:Army

Document Type:Capstone Project

Document:#79311678


The United States Army has a history of instilling and enforcing discipline within its ranks. However, with every passing year come changes in the way society thinks and acts. New social values are created and fostered, and leaders in the U.S. Army must address these changes in order to maintain continuity of standards and discipline from one generation to the next (Wardynski). Thus, as the new generation of soldiers enters the United States Army, new challenges await leadership. The evolving world of social media is just one of the challenges that require leaders to be proactive in their approach to army standards and its enforcement. Soldiers have access to the internet in a deployed environment and use this platform in positive ways but also use social media in ways that bring harm to the Army values and heritage. Leaders need to walk a fine line between the soldiers rights to privacy and operational security.

In order to lead effectively, understanding of the new generation’s needs and expectations has to be considered at the same time that the Army’s own standards and expectations are communicated to new soldiers. The Army cannot forego one while observing only the other and vice versa. The Army has to maintain its standards and discipline but unless it understands the obstacles that prevent soldiers from knowing what it means to be a professional, the vision the Army has for itself, the standards it relies upon, and the discipline it needs to thrive will be lacking—as is currently the case (Allen, 2012). This essay will discuss the challenges and opportunities Army leaders face and also how leaders must maintain discipline in their ranks.

Statement of the Problem

The problem that is faced by leaders in the Army today is that they see new soldiers coming out of basic training without any confidence or discipline (Frost, 2018). To that end, Frost (2018) states that a new Basic Combat Training (BCT) program has been developed that is designed to reinforce discipline and build the new soldier’s confidence. Frost (2018) indicates that the new BCT program fixes the defects in the old BCT program that were producing undisciplined and unconfident soldiers. However, there has been no study indicating what today’s Army leaders think of the new BCT program or what they believe the real issues are when it comes to instilling discipline in the new generation of soldiers. Thus, there is a need for a qualitative study that allows for the exploration of viewpoints among military leaders that can be compared with viewpoints of new soldiers so as to see how what the actual perspectives are like and how great the distance is between them—i.e., how much bridging needs to occur in order to get new soldiers aligned with leaders in the Army.

Research Questions and Strategy

The design for this study is to interview military leaders and new soldiers about their perspectives on discipline and standards. The aim is to see what they know, what they believe, where they want to be, and how they think they can best get there. It is assumed that leaders will have more perspective on this issue than new soldiers. However, by interviewing the new soldiers the objective is to gauge their attitudes on standards and discipline and to assess their willingness to be challenged, since the basis of the new BCT program is that new recruits will rise to the challenge when standards are raised and discipline training is doubled early on (Frost, 2018).

The research questions that this study asks are:

1) What do leaders in the Army…

Some parts of this document are missing

Click here to view full document

…(2012). The research indicates that past behavior is a good predictor of future performance and too many soldiers are being promoted who have poor quality records when it comes to past behavior.

Frost (2018) suggests that the way to fix the problem is to use the new Basic Combat Training program, which focuses more on instilling discipline in the early weeks of the program and less on basic skills. By focusing more on discipline, Frost (2018) argues that new recruits will be able to uphold higher standards of behavior. When leaders challenge the new recruits, the soldiers are more likely to rise to the challenge, so leaders should not be fearful of challenging soldiers during the training process. This is why Frost (2018) recommends the new BCT program over the old one.

Conclusion

In order to lead effectively, understanding of the new generation’s needs and expectations has to be considered at the same time that the Army’s own standards and expectations are communicated to new soldiers. The standards of the Army have been lowered in the past and this is a problem because the military in the coming years is going to need leaders and soldiers of high-quality moral fiber. Discipline is needed in the Army now more than ever before, and it is sorely lacking according to the research. This study aims to explore the perspectives of military leaders and soldiers to better understand what the problem is and how it can be addressed. The literature on the subject shows that declining standards and discipline is a major factor across the board and that if the military does not do something to address the issue the military will not be able to stand up to enemy combatants or rely on technological superiority alone. The literature indicates that more focus…


Sample Source(s) Used

References

Allen, C. D. (2012). Back to Basics: The Army Must Reinforce Standards of Discipline. Carlisle, PA: Army War College Carlisle Barracks.

Frost, M. (2018). Back to the basics with pride and discipline. Retrieved from https://www.ausa.org/articles/back-basics-pride-and-discipline

Wardynski, C., Lyle, D. S., & Colarusso, M. J. (2009). Towards a US Army officer corps strategy for success: A proposed human capital model focused upon talent (Vol. 1). Carlisle, PA: Strategic Studies Institute.

Cite this Document

Join thousands of other students and "spark your studies."

Sign Up for FREE
Related Documents

Studyspark Study Document

Discipline the Navy Has a Stated Mission

Pages: 6 (1544 words) Subject: Military Document: #86599885

Discipline The Navy has a stated mission to maintain, train and equip combat-ready Naval forces capable of winning wars, deterring aggression, and maintaining freedom of the seas. This mission requires the active involvement, participation, and support of the troops that make up the Navy. I understand that as a service member, I have a role to play in the Navy's ability to achieve its mission. I understand the importance of

Studyspark Study Document

Command and Its Different Responsibilities

Pages: 5 (1741 words) Sources: 1 Subject: Military Document: #84594921

Army Regulation 600-20 Command and the different Army Responsibilities Command aspects of medical care It will be necessary for a Soldier at AD or ADT to submit to medical care which is important for the survival of his or her life, lessen excessive suffering, or secure or preserve the health of others. The examination of any Soldier may be ordered by Commanders when necessary. It will be decided by the medical treatment facility

Studyspark Study Document

National Guard and the National

Pages: 5 (1606 words) Sources: 4 Subject: American History Document: #26647100

Pershing had G-1 dealing with personnel; G-2 dealt with intelligence; G-3 deals with operations and training; G-4 was the supply division; and G-5 was focused on "strategic planning" (Madloff, 66). Meanwhile, the Congressional Digest (the official federal publication that explains legislation) in 1934 provided some basic details on the Act of 1920. Beyond what has already been described vis-a-vis the 1920 Act, the Congressional Digest explains that the Act fixed

Studyspark Study Document

Phoenix Program Lessons to Iraq

Pages: 75 (19225 words) Sources: 50 Subject: Military Document: #51380939

(MACV Dir 381-41) This document is one of the first confidential memorandums associated with the Phoenix Program, which details in 1967 the mostly U.S. involvement in counterinsurgency intelligence and activities and discusses the future training and development of South Vietnam forces to serve the same function, that had been supported by the U.S. In civilian (mostly CIA) and military roles. The document stresses that the U.S. role is to

Studyspark Study Document

Classroom Behavior Management Policies Title

Pages: 80 (23815 words) Sources: 31 Subject: Sociology Document: #72993264

According to Bales, 1999, the concept behind SYMLOG is that "every act of behavior takes place in a larger context, that it is a part of an interactive field of influences." Further, "the approach assumes that one needs to understand the larger context -- person, interpersonal, group, and external situation -- in order to understand the patterns of behavior and to influence them successfully." With SYMLOG, measurement procedures are

Studyspark Study Document

Same-Sex Marriage in Defense of

Pages: 10 (3358 words) Sources: 1+ Subject: Women's Issues - Sexuality Document: #28350395

Ruth and Naomi appear to be lesbians. In fact, the statements made by Ruth to Naomi mirror echo the familiar "till death do us part" used in marriage ceremonies (Robinson, "Same-Sex"). King David of Israel may also have been in a homosexual relationship with Jonathan, the son of King Saul. "David left his parents home and moved to Saul's where he would be with Jonathan" (Robinson, "Same-Sex). Furthermore, the

Join thousands of other students and

"spark your studies".