Studyspark Study Document

Volkswagen Emissions Fraud Essay

Related Topics: Stock Compensation Cheating Fraud

Pages:4 (1299 words)

Sources:4

Subject:Business

Topic:Volkswagen

Document Type:Essay

Document:#48904563


Decisions Influenced by Bias

Volkswagen produced vehicles that were equipped with emissions controls that were designed to shut off once the cars had passed regulatory tests. As s result, not only did the cars pollute more in real life than in those tests, but the company benefitted from these tests financially, because they showed that diesel engines were less polluting than gasoline ones. The result was misleading the public, making the company eligible for subsidies that gave it competitive benefit, and misleading the public, as many people may have chosen to buy a Volkswagen in part based on the emissions performance of the vehicles (Parloff, 2018).

Biases at Play

There were a few different biases at play in the Volkswagen case that can be unpacked. The first of these is the bias towards the optimal motivations of executive action. The company’s senior executive at the time, Martin Winterkorn, was aware of the practice when he ascended to his new role – and had been one of its driving forces during implementation. Further, he continued the practice, and was eventually brought up on fraud charges in the US as a result (Smith, 2018).

The first bias was likely the decision between duty – duty to shareholders to enhance the stock price, and duty to the public and regulators to provide emissions information that was accurate. The duty to regulators was legal. The duty to shareholders is real, but not legal, but it also included a duty to himself, as he would also benefit from an increase in the share price. The duty to the buyers is ethical, but not legal, and can probably be interpreted in a number of ways. Thus, WInterkorn’s actions – and indeed the actions of all at Volkswagen in this case – were influenced by personal gain.

Palmiter (2017) provides some insight into the different ethical conflicts that can arise. One is the conflict between fairness and cheating. In this case, the fairness certainly includes shareholders, who have at least some priority in the hierarchy of stakeholders. The author advances the idea that non-shareholder constituents should have the same level of interests as shareholders, but of course when the CEO’s personal wealth is heavily invested in what is good for the shareholders, the CEO will have a distinctly different perspective on the matter. That bias seems to move away from the concept…

Some parts of this document are missing

Click here to view full document

…interest in the first place, not to mention his participation in the project initially.

Because moral hazard is often created when there is a gap between the time period for the reward and the behaviors desired, Volkswagen either deliberately or accidentally created moral hazard in hiring Winterkorn to the top job (Cook, 2008). Therefore, the company had the opportunity to reduce the risk of such fraud by removing much of the moral hazard concerned with equity-based compensation and the misalignment of corporate goals and executive goals. This is done at the level of executive compensation structure, because once the moral hazard itself is created, the likelihood of unethical behavior is much higher. This is why in the Untied States, the Sarbanes-Oxley Act build into its structure prison terms for senior executives engaged in fraud, as a means of balancing out the moral hazard associated with equity-based compensation.

Conclusion

The Volkswagen emissions fraud was the result of moral hazard, which in turn was created by bias towards actions that benefit oneself that were not effectively counterbalanced by actions that benefited either the long-term shareholders or by non-shareholder interests. As such, Volkswagen’s Board bears much of the responsibility, though of…


Sample Source(s) Used

References

Ganti, A. (2019) Rationcal choice theory. Investopedia. Retrieved January 18, 2020 from https://www.investopedia.com/terms/r/rational-choice-theory.asp

Palmiter, A. (no date). Corporate governance as moral psychology. In possession of the author.

Parloff, R. (2018) How VW paid $25 billion for dieselgate – and got off easy. Business Ethics. Retrieved January 18, 2020 from https://business-ethics.com/2018/02/08/1638-how-vw-paid-25-billion-for-dieselgate-and-got-off-easy/

Smith, A. (2018) Volkswagen ex-CEO charged with fraud in diesel emissions scandal. CNN. Retrieved January 18, 2020 from https://money.cnn.com/2018/05/03/news/companies/winterkorn-vw-diesel-scandal/index.html

Cite this Document

Join thousands of other students and "spark your studies."

Sign Up for FREE
Related Documents

Studyspark Study Document

Business Ethics in Volkswagen Emissions Scandal

Pages: 7 (2029 words) Sources: 10 Subject: Business - Ethics Document: #17888971

Crisis Management in VW’s ‘Dieselgate’ Scandal
Trust is the most important factor in the success of any organization. This trust extends to all levels of stakeholders. If customers feel that they cannot trust the company for any reason, they will not purchase their products. Stakeholders have to trust that the organization will make sound business decisions to keep profits high and manage value. This is becoming even more prominent in

Studyspark Study Document

Volkswagen Guessed Speculated That It Could Fool the EPA

Pages: 13 (1157 words) Sources: 2 Subject: Geography Document: #26198104

Meta-Analysis When it comes to the Volkswagen scandal, the real cost in human terms could be sixty or more premature deaths, according to an environmental study reported in Time. The 482,000 dirty diesel Volkswagen engines (sold in the U.S.) spewed enormous amounts of nitrogen oxide into the air for years before the deceptive software was discovered. The study by the peer-reviewed journal Environmental Research Letters suggests that "... as many

Studyspark Study Document

Vw and the Emissions Testing Scandal

Pages: 3 (928 words) Sources: 1 Subject: Sports - College Document: #26186613

Car companies have made many promises over the years. From reduced emissions, to steady driving, to conserving fuel, car companies try to please the public with sometimes-ludicrous claims. Volkswagen is one of those companies, promising their customers cars the produce less emissions. They did deliver said promise. However, that was only in test mode. In fact, their cars produced more than expected outside of test mode. Volkswagen has not been all

Studyspark Study Document

Application of Ethical Decision Making Models to Volkswagen S Diesel Scandal...

Pages: 8 (3359 words) Sources: 5 Subject: Law - Constitutional Law Document: #86031665

Managerial Social Responsibility - Volkswagen Diesel Scandal In 2015, Volkswagen was accused of installing secret software in its engine management computers to cheat strict fuel economy and emissions tests. In order to determine the ethical decision Volkswagen should have made, one can use ethical decision-making models, such as: Utilitarianism; Kantian Ethics; Ethical Rights; and Distributive Justice. Though these four models use different approaches, one or more of them can result in

Studyspark Study Document

Changes in Project Management at Volkswagen

Pages: 7 (2138 words) Sources: 7 Subject: Management Document: #78748282

Project Management at VolkswagenIntroductionIn 2015, Volkswagen was caught cheating on emissions tests, sparking a worldwide scandal. The company was found to have installed software on its diesel cars that would alter the engine\\\'s performance during emissions testing, making the cars appear to be more environmentally friendly than they actually were. In the wake of the scandal, Volkswagen faced enormous fines and intense public scrutiny. So, what could the company have

Studyspark Study Document

Hypocrisy and Accountability at Volkswagen

Pages: 7 (1953 words) Sources: 1 Subject: Leadership Document: #99546362

Dieselgate Case AnalysisWhat?The situation presented in the case study by Schuetz (2016) focuses on VW Group and the emissions scandal that occurred in 2015 just when the company was about to reach a significant milestone in its long-term development plan. VW had been working to become the largest automaker in the world, an intrepid plan for a company that started out of a bombed-out factory in post-war Germany. However, it

Join thousands of other students and

"spark your studies".