Studyspark Study Document

Immigration Reform Essay

Pages:5 (1424 words)

Sources:6

Subject:Government

Topic:Immigration Reform

Document Type:Essay

Document:#73100593


Why Immigration Reform is Needed

Immigration reform has almost always been a thorny issue in America. Though it is popularly believed that America was born of a nation of immigrants, the reality is that the original 13 colonies largely consisted of individuals from one specific part of Europe—England—and from the time of the War for Independence onward it was a White Anglo-Saxon Protestant (WASPs) ethic that served as the fulcrum for American power and politics. It was this fulcrum that established the concept of “Manifest Destiny”—i.e., the idea that it was America’s (that is, the WASP’s) destiny in life to expand and take over the land as far as it could see (O’Sullivan). “Manifest Destiny” was used to justify taking land from Mexico and it was implicitly used to justify American expansionism overseas. In other words, WASPs wanted to expand their control and exert their influence and power. The arrival of immigrants from other parts of the world was never really something that sat comfortable with them. That is why they passed immigration and naturalization laws restricting the rights of Asians, Jews, and Catholics in the 19th century. The Exclusion Act restrict the rights of Chinese immigrants (Hafetz), the Irish were viewed as a political (and social) threat (McCaffrey), and Mexicans were almost always treated poorly—particularly via the Bracero Program (Calavita). Thus, in this context, talk today of immigration reform has to be understood as a long process of push and pull in which ethnic groups have fought back against the WASP establishment and attempted to ensure that immigrants be allowed to continue to come to the U.S. This paper will discuss the issue of immigration reform and show what the problem is and how to solve it.

The current issue with immigration today is that President Trump wants to build a border wall to stop illegal immigration. Many radical Democrats want more of an open borders policy where immigrants can come into the country, receive services (like free health care) and even vote, without ever having to go through a naturalization process or become citizens. And while the plaque on the Statue of Liberty reads: “Give me your tired, your poor, Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free, The wretched refuse of your teeming shore. Send these, the homeless, tempest-tossed to me, I lift my lamp beside the golden door!”—the reality is that America has always placed a limit on the number of immigrants who are permitted in at any one time. When it was in U.S. corporate interests (i.e., WASP interests), immigrants were welcomed: this was the case when the Chinese were used to build the railroads in the 19th century (Hafetz) and when Mexican laborers were needed in the West during WWII and so were encouraged to emigrate under the Bracero…

Some parts of this document are missing

Click here to view full document

…is completed and to also measure the cases of drug dealing and violence committed by illegal immigrants over that same time period. The costs spent on immigrants, too, should be measured. Taking these measurements over a ten year time period will show whether the border wall in conjunction with the social services pairing project was successful or not. If the measurements show no real or substantial change in terms of crime, drug dealing and cost, it would mean the wall and the social worker program was not a successful solution. If however it is seen that more immigrants are coming into the country legally than illegally, that crime and drug dealing has been reduced, and that immigrants are being better supported to stand on their own without relying heavily on government subsidies and taxpayers, it could be said that the intervention is a success.

In conclusion, the best way to address the problem of immigration reform may be to give the Trump Administration what it wants but also to make sure that immigrants who do come in are given social worker support to ensure a fair chance at making it. This would be the most humane and effective way to address the issue, considering both the WASP ethic still in play and the need to be fair to all. It is a solution that could be achieved and measured to see if it is…


Sample Source(s) Used

Works Cited

Bartoletti, Susan C. 2001. Black Potatoes: The Story of the Great Irish Famine, 1845-1850. New York, NY: Houghton Mifflin.

Calavita, Kitty. Inside the State: The Bracero Program, Immigration, and the I. N. S. New York, NY: Routledge, 1992.

Federation for American Immigration Reform. “The costs of illegal immigration on United States taxpayers—2013 edition.” FAIR. https://fairus.org/issue/publications-resources/fiscal-burden-illegal-Immigration-2013

Hafetz, J. “Immigration and national security law: Converging approaches to state power, individual rights, and judicial review.” ILSA Journal of International and Comparative Law 18.3. (2012): 628.

O’Sullivan, J. L. “Manifest Destiny,” in Voices of Freedom: A Documentary History, 4th edition, ed. Eric Foner. New York: W.W. Norton, 2014.

McCaffrey, Lawrence John. The Irish Catholic Diaspora in America. CUA Press, 1997.

Cite this Document

Join thousands of other students and "spark your studies."

Sign Up for FREE
Related Documents

Studyspark Study Document

Immigration Reform

Pages: 5 (1512 words) Sources: 3 Subject: Healthcare Document: #82044293

Immigration Reform The social justice implications of Immigration Reform Strangers are behind the formation of the beautiful land of America. The American land has flourishes because it is being by different sources. This rooted on the varied nourishments of different people, cultures, and traditions. Immigration reforms have made the U.S. A strong and vibrant nation. Reforms of immigration have been fostering the rich dynamism in the country. Appropriate welcoming of foreign visitors

Studyspark Study Document

Immigration Reform

Pages: 2 (618 words) Sources: 2 Subject: Government Document: #62454571

Immigration Reform The American political system appears to be engaged in a chaotic state of confusion as many contradictory policies and actions are taking place in national society. Immigration reform is one of the main issues coming from the media machines that dictate and pace the political discussions taking place. The purpose of this essay is to describe the relationship between immigration reform and homeland security. The current pace of societal change

Studyspark Study Document

Immigration Reform There Is a Broad Based

Pages: 9 (2649 words) Sources: 8 Subject: Government Document: #93795452

Immigration Reform There is a broad based agreement of a need for immigration reform. In recent months and years, immigration reform has become an important political issue. However, there is some disagreement as to what precisely this reform will look like. On one hand, there is talk about amnesty for illegal immigrants who are currently in the country, an issue that has proved divisive (Grant, 2012). One the other hand, technology

Studyspark Study Document

Immigration Reform Dream Act

Pages: 5 (1686 words) Sources: 3 Subject: American History Document: #98120978

Immigration Reform and the Dream Act Regardless of one's individual political position, a study of immigration in modern America reveals that the current immigration system is not working. Preferential treatment of immigrants from some countries over immigrants from other countries and preferential treatment of high-wage immigrants combined with policies of active deportation reflect a reality that no longer exists in America. The reality is that there are huge numbers of undocumented

Studyspark Study Document

Immigration Reform There Are Many

Pages: 8 (3336 words) Sources: 6 Subject: American History Document: #74485326

5 billion per year. "(Costs of Illegal Immigration to New Yorkers) In most cases, studies show that the central areas of expenditure are related to immigration are education, health care and incarceration resulting from illegal immigration. (Costs of Illegal Immigration to New Yorkers) Education is of particular concern. In New York, more than $4.3 billion annually is spent on education for the children of illegal immigrants. The number of K-12 public

Studyspark Study Document

Immigration Reform the Bush Administration

Pages: 3 (838 words) Sources: 1+ Subject: American History Document: #30152902

These groups believe that the program is giving blanket amnesty and encouraging more illegal immigration. President Bush denies that the program promotes amnesty. "I oppose amnesty, placing undocumented workers on the automatic path to citizenship," he said (FOX, 2004). "Granting amnesty encourages violation of our laws and perpetuates illegal immigration. America is a welcoming country, but citizenship must not be the automatic reward for violating the laws of America." While the

Join thousands of other students and

"spark your studies".