Study Document
Healthcare Rationing and Rights Essay
Pages:2 (796 words)
Sources:2
Subject:Health
Topic:Patient Rights
Document Type:Essay
Document:#99136644
Libertarianism
In what sense is Judge Napolitano's view of health care libertarian?
There are several reasons it is libertarian. First, libertarianism is against the healthcare mandate in that they would be against a person being forced to buy anything, even healthcare. Also, Napolitano in particular does not believe healthcare is a right as it is not defined or stated in the United States Constitution. Indeed, the United States was founded in the late 1700's and such an idea would be foreign. Further, Social Security and Medicare did not come into its current form until the 1930's and 1960's. However, libertarians hold that they should be allowed to buy healthcare if they want but that mandating the same and calling it a right are both wrong (Wilson, 2014; YouTube, 2016).
How does Daniels relate health care to fair equality of opportunity? If health care is related to equal opportunity, and given the fact that the elderly doesn't really have a range of opportunities before them, should we withhold health care from them? How does Daniels answer this question?
Daniels addresses the plight of the elderly by saying prior that a properly designed healthcare system will be constrained by budgets that are reasonable and proper. He comes back to that argument by stating that healthcare allocations should not matter due to stage of live. At the same time, he notes that treating people differently based on stage of life is not the same thing as doing the same thing for different race and age. In response to this factor, Daniels asserts that healthcare should be properly allocated over the lifespan of a person rather than given in one chunk at any given time. This may run counter to the idea that many to most healthcare expenses are incurred by a person as they reach the end part of their life but Daniels does not really make a mention of this as a caveat (Daniels, 2016).
3. What solution does Daniels offer to the rationing problem of limited health care resources?
Daniels is pretty clear in his words that "pure" rationing by age is "permissible." The precise quote is "under conditions of scarcity, this implies "pure" rationing by age (where age is not proxy for other traits) is permissible" (Daniels). He further says that there is the need to set priorities in terms of how care should be allocated. He says it is…
Sample Source(s) Used
References
Daniels, N. (2016). Justice, Health and Healthcare. Harvard University. Retrieved 12 February 2016, from http://www.hsph.harvard.edu/benchmark/ndaniels/pdf/justice_health.pdf
Wilson, J. (2014). Judge Napolitano On the Two Party System. A Libertarian Future. Retrieved 12 February 2016, from http://alibertarianfuture.com/famous-libertarians/judge-napolitano-two-party-system/#sthash.4ILNt4fx.dpbs
YouTube. (2016). Health Care Insurance is NOT A RIGHT - Part 1 of 2. YouTube. Retrieved 12 February 2016, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NMbbCTVt7Qg
Related Documents
Study Document
Healthcare Rationing
Ethical Analysis of Healthcare Rationing The topic of health care rationing has been the subject of debate in the U.S. The last few years as government expenditures on health care have far exceeded budgeted levels. Central to the concern is the ethical issue over whether it is better if fewer Americans profit with a greater amount of health resource allocation or if the majority benefit to a lesser degree for
Study Document
Health Care Reform to Place
And, secondly, what's the rush? If this is so good for us and everyone understands the program, then what is the answer to those two questions? The answers are, in order, because most Americans have no clue what the program is due to the fact that the menu changes so often and so quickly and all we get is sound bites. What's the rush? So politicians like Mr. Obama and
Study Document
Healthcare Reform Review of Literature:
(Menzel, 1990, p. 3) Fisher, Berwick, & Davis alude to the idea of integration in health care, with providers linking as well as creating networks of electronic medical records and other cost improvement tactics. The United States and other nations over the last twenty or so years, have begun a sweeping change in health care delivery, regarding the manner in which health information is input, stored and accessed. Computer use
Study Document
Healthcare Must Be Provided by the Government to All Citizens Who Cannot Afford the Cost...
Health Care As human beings, our health and longevity have never been better. Many people today live to 100 years and beyond, and often in good and active health. One of the major reasons for this is better health care and more access to health care for more people. On the other hand, however, many people do not have access to the same health care services as others. Often, the main
Study Document
Health Care in the U.S. and Spain
Health Care in the U.S. And Spain What Can the U.S. Learn About Health Care from Spain? In 2009, Spain's single-payer health care system was ranked the seventh best in the world by the World Health Organization (Socolovsky, 2009). By comparison, the U.S. health care system ranted at 37 (Satiroglou, 2009). The Spanish system offers coverage as a right of citizenship that is constitutionally guaranteed. Spanish residents pay no expenses out-of-pocket, with
Study Document
Healthcare Reform Revised
Healthcare Reform Revised We know that the burden of diseases is increasing all over the world. The percentage of people suffering from diabetes, cardiovascular and pulmonary diseases has considerably increased in the last decade. It is noteworthy here that the importance of preventive care now comes at par with the importance of curative care. Considering the prevalence of diseases and the health status of the American population, President Obama introduced a