Alternative Sentencing Including Shock Probation and Shock Parole Essay

prison overcrowding and recidivism major problems in criminal justice, alternatives to incarceration become more salient than ever before. One of the most common alternatives to incarceration is probation: an alternative sentence to prison time that generally involves supervision by an appointed parole officer or group of officers. Probation allows the individual to go about his or her daily life including occupational activities and family life. Therefore, probation does reduce the harm associated with prisoner re-entry, and minimizes the risks associated with dismantling families and communities. Probation may be especially effective for offenses that are nonviolent in nature, including drug offences.

Parole is an early release from a prison sentence, offered to individuals based on good behavior in prison, lack of risk for re-offense, or minimal threat to society. Like probation, parole helps reduce prison populations. Parole by definition means the individual did spend some time in prison, but it also means that the original sentence was shorter than its maximum mandate. In some cases, probation may be part of the parole package. In other words, a person released on parole may be on an interim period of probation before being fully released from criminal justice monitoring. In addition to probation and parole, there are a slew of other alternative sentencing options judges may issue. These other alternatives vary from state to state, and judges use their discretion when issuing them. Alternatives include community service or participation in drug rehabilitation programs.

Shock probation and shock parole are related concepts, and both are forms of alternative sentences. Empirical research does show that shock probation and shock parole "reduce incarceration and shorten the length of imprisonment," leading to desirable outcomes in the criminal justice system including reduced recidivism and cost savings (Scott, Dinitz & Shiclior, 2010, p. 113). Both shock probation and shock parole involve a conscientious decision on the part of the judge to issue a prison sentence with the intention of providing early release (parole) or conditional release (probation). The availability of shock probation and shock parole as alternative sentences varies from state to state, and is largely a matter of prosecutorial and judicial discretion. In other words, the prosecuting attorneys may view shock probation and shock parole as elements in the plea bargaining process, while judges may use shock probation and shock parole as options on the continuum between being too lenient and too strict. Whether or not…