Studyspark Study Document

Psychology As a Science Psychology Is a Essay

Pages:5 (1545 words)


Subject:Social Science


Document Type:Essay



Psychology is a relatively new field of science as opposed to the natural sciences because it was born out of the spirit of humanism after the Renaissance (Hergenhahn, 108). As a result, methods and norms in the field are still being developed. In addition, the subject matter of the field includes the mind, personality and other intangible entities that cannot be subjected to the same kind of testing and experimentation as in medicine or physics.

Psychology has intended to become a branch of science to gain greater credibility and reliability for its claims. Science is recognized as objective whereas other fields may be treated as subjective and based on philosophical speculation rather than rigorous experimentation and research. In fact, the history of science in the modern world can be traced to the moment in 1600 when William Gilbert published his work on magnetism based on objective analysis and experimentation as opposed to the philosophical approach of Aristotelianism prevalent in those days. To be considered a science, therefore, psychology would have to accommodate experimentation and objective analysis of its observations in the methodology.

Science involves repeated experiments and trials to test a hypothesis. Therefore, psychology should possess the capacity for hypotheses to be developed based on observations and then tested through controlled experiments to verify or negate those hypotheses. There should be adequate arrangements for laboratories and other contexts where factors can be controlled and the subjects of the experiment monitored for their observations (McDougall, 4). The psychologists should also consider the extent to which experiments on human beings can be conducted as this could have social costs for the study. Currently, experiments on the same scale of control as those in natural sciences cannot be performed in psychology.

Psychology has been studied from a variety of perspectives that may not all be considered as scientific. They are not based on observation, experimentation and testing of hypotheses. One of these perspectives is the psychodynamic perspective. Developed and popularized by the efforts of Freud, this perspective is based on a unique conceptualization of the human mind. Freud believed that the human mind was comprised of the conscious and the subconscious and that a number of innate drives and suppressed desires affected human behavior. This was not a scientific approach because the claims of Freudian psychology could not be tested empirically. Hence, these claims were not verifiable and hence could not be relied upon.

A second perspective of psychology that is not scientific is the humanistic perspective. This approach was born out of the spirit of the Renaissance and emphasized the primacy of human experiences in explaining human and social behavior. This approach also tried to explain how human behavior could be changed in addition to how it was shaped by environmental forces. It emphasized the power of human will and independence despite environmental factors affecting behavior. The humanists stressed that behavior could be changed through the power of the will and by conscious effort. This perspective was openly subjective in its orientation and was therefore inappropriate for scientific approval. There was no consistent set of rules for validating or disproving any claims as any explanation based on unique personal experiences was valid.

Similarly, other approaches that are artistic or theological in nature cannot be classified as scientific because they do not stand up to objective scrutiny. The claims and conclusions of these perspectives cannot be proved through experimentation and logic. Their findings are not based on reliable results that can be described as constant for a given set of environmental factors. Therefore, approaches such as the psychodynamic approach and the humanistic perspective are philosophical in nature as opposed to being scientific. Scientific psychology is based on experiments and observations. An example is behaviorism which tries to explain how human beings and animals learn new behaviors through experimentation (Galotti, 9). Classic experiments include those on classical and operant conditioning where repeated trials were used to establish the stimulus-response relationships on which acquisition of new behaviors is based.

Psychology should differ from other branches of science, in particular natural and physical sciences because of a number of social and ethical questions that impinge upon the study of psychological issues. The distinguishing feature of psychology compared to other sciences is that the subject matter of psychology is human beings. Given this situation, it is difficult for psychology to undertake experiments involving human beings and their personal and social actions at the same level as with animals or inanimate objects. Experiments in psychology cannot incorporate laboratory experiments with human beings for extended periods of time because invading the privacy of human beings poses ethical and moral questions. It is also difficult for psychologists to conduct experiments to observe changes in generations of human beings as opposed to studying similar changes in animals or plants. Therefore, psychology needs to depend on retrospective studies as part of its scientific methodology.

The content of scientific psychology is in the form of theories of behavior and perception. These theories are based on the assumption that the human motives can be gleaned from behavior and self-reporting. Therefore, observation and self-report are the most common ways used in scientific psychology to conduct research and gather evidence. The assumption underlying the content of scientific psychology is that the content is uniformly applicable within the population under study. For instance, the conclusions about human behavior under stress are assumed to be uniformly explainable by instances of human stress behavior within the population. The content of scientific psychology is also based on the assumption that it can be used to predict human behavior and actions. So the behavior of people entering a football stadium can be predicted based on the behavior of visitors to a football stadium in earlier instances. On the other hand, the assumptions also include the caveat that human behavior is not entirely predictable and that various other factors may enter the picture to complicate it. External pressure through institutional norms, socialization and free will may also modify the outcome.

Evaluating psychological theories therefore involves a process of rigorous intellectual activity and objective analysis of alternative theories. Such an approach helps to breed objectivity and support a consistent criterion for theory evaluation. At times, several theories may be put forward to explain certain concepts r phenomena. In evaluating a psychological theory, the principal ideas to consider are the assumptions. Generally, the theories that are preferred are those that are based on assumptions that are fewer in number (Kalat, 31). Theories with fewer assumptions are assumed to be more efficient than theories that explain the same phenomena but are based on numerous assumptions. It is also preferable to support psychological theories that are based on simple assumptions as opposed to complex ones (Kalat, 31). Simple assumptions reflect clarity of ideas and concepts. A third criterion for evaluating psychological theories, particularly when there are other theories that explain the same phenomena, is whether the theory supports or complements other theories on the subject (Kalat, 31). The theory should also distinguish between correlation and causation (Plotnik & Kouyoumdijan, 33). In any field of scientific study, a theoretical framework is constructed by integrated theories. Therefore, evaluating psychological theories on the basis of their support to one another helps the theorist to create a strong theoretical framework.

At times, several theories may be presented for evaluation before psychologists. Given the historical evolution of the field, some of these theories may be based on common sense or folk wisdom while others may be based on scientific explanation and experimentation. It is therefore, important that the theories e identified as such and only those theories be accepted that possess the characteristics of a scientific theory. The theories that should be selected are those that carry conclusions that can be verified through repeating the experiments in…

Sample Source(s) Used


Galotti, Kathleen M. Cognitive Psychology. 4. Thomson Wadsworth, 2008. 9. Print.

Hergenhahn, B.R. An Introduction to the History of Psychology. 6. Cengage Learning, 2009. 108. Print.

Kalat, James W. Introduction to Psychology. 9. Cengage Learning, 2011. 31. Print.

McDougall, William. A Textbook of Psychology. Discovery Publishing House. 2011. 4. Print.

Cite this Document

Join thousands of other students and "spark your studies."

Sign Up for FREE
Related Documents

Studyspark Study Document

Psychology Is an Important Field of Study

Pages: 3 (1409 words) Sources: 10 Subject: Psychology Document: #88059866

Psychology is an important field of study mainly because it can be used to enhance the lives of people as it increases an individual's level of self-understanding, well-being, and quality of relationships. The main reason for the impact of psychology on people's lives is because this field focuses on describing, explaining, predicting, and controlling the mental and behavioral processes of an individual. As a broad field of study, the field

Studyspark Study Document

Psychology Is Considered to Be an Area

Pages: 10 (2806 words) Sources: 10 Subject: Psychology Document: #87364405

Psychology is considered to be an area of study that involves behavior. Behavior is demonstrated in a lot of diverse areas in the field of psychology. Some of these examples are mental illness, relationships, sexuality, depression, family dynamics, or culture. Accepting of behavior is picked up by various techniques and it could be from society or changes in individuals or the overall population. Psychologists look at various factors such as

Studyspark Study Document

Psychology's Rodney Dangerfield Problem the

Pages: 2 (624 words) Sources: 2 Subject: Psychology Document: #46831029

One of the most salient measures that a psychologist can take is to base all of his work, and particularly his or her conclusions or findings, in the methodology befitting of true psychological and scientific processes. This means utilizing empirical evidence and evidence-based practices to substantiate findings before publicizing any sorts of claims surrounding their implications. This sort of testing (which author Scott Lillenfeld wrote the public believes is

Studyspark Study Document

Psychology History a Brief History of Psychology

Pages: 3 (935 words) Sources: 2 Subject: Psychology Document: #90851949

Psychology History A Brief History of Psychology The study of psychology is now deeply entrenched in our society's understand as to how a human, and specifically the human mind, functions. Understanding one's psychological needs is necessary in daily life in order to understand how to cope with various stresses and emotions. However, many decades ago, such ideas were truly visionary, as psychology was not considered a true scientific subject, and many who

Studyspark Study Document

Psychology Is a Multifaceted Field

Pages: 5 (1705 words) Sources: 1+ Subject: Psychology Document: #85096253

References Blocher, DH (2000). The Evolution of Counseling Psychology. New York: Springer. Darlington, Y., & Scott, D. (2002). Qualitative Research in Practice: Stories from the Field / . Crows Nest, N.S.W.: Allen & Unwin. Hoagwood, K., Jensen, P.S., & Fisher, C.B. (Eds.). (1996). Ethical Issues in Mental Health Research with Children and Adolescents. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Lewis, D. (1960). Quantitative Methods in Psychology. New York: McGraw-Hill Book Company. Newman,

Studyspark Study Document

Psychology Describe the Relationship Between Behaviorism and

Pages: 7 (2413 words) Sources: 1 Subject: Psychology Document: #10399565

Psychology Describe the relationship between Behaviorism and Cognitive psychology as movements within the science of psychology in the last century. Is one better than the other? Why or why not? Compare and contrast. The Behavioral School of thought, founded by BF Skinner and his classical conditioning approach was the natural precedent of Freud's psychoanalytical approach. According to behaviorism, all behavior is learnt and that people can be taught various things by conditioning

Join thousands of other students and

"spark your studies".