Studyspark Study Document

The Extent to Which Group Policy Evaluation Vs. Individual Evaluation Differ Essay

Pages:3 (999 words)

Sources:3

Subject:English

Topic:Evaluation

Document Type:Essay

Document:#33568686


Problems That Arise When Groups are Categorized as Individuals

The difficulty of determining the extent to which group policy evaluation vs. individual evaluations differ is that context is the deciding factor, and contextual factors are always shifting. Therefore, a case by case analysis is required rather than a one size fits all universal evaluation. As Briggs and Helms (2015) explain, there are actors and roles and the inputs and outputs of each impact one another so that the relationship between parts, between groups and individuals is really a dynamic one.

One of the important points that Reich (2010) makes is that groups are not individuals and should not be counted as such, because it alters the character of the population when they are. He cites the decision in Citizens United vs. the Federal Election Commission, which led to the creation of the super political action committee (PAC). The super PAC now is permitted to spend without limits on election campaigns so long as the candidate is not involved. The group has been given the same rights as the individual and the effect is that the group becomes more powerful than the individual, as it has more influence.

This is problematic because one is evaluating policy based on group vs. individual differences and yet policymakers and lobbyists are being influenced by groups and individuals in different ways. As Briggs and Helms (2015) point out, both groups and individuals will have their policy entrepreneurs, who are “people willing to invest their resources in return for future policies they favor” (p. 22). That exchange, however, is the issue that Reich (2010) touches on: the more well-financed group will have an advantage of the less well-financed individual.

Another issue is that the small group may not represent the larger population’s interests at all, while a larger group might yet it will have less impact on policy. Policy evaluation itself can be undermined by the inputs of powerful groups, and so as Schaufele et…

Some parts of this document are missing

Click here to view full document

…trusted based on their authority in the field, their voices and opinions can be used to move a group to accept the conclusion of the expert. Statistics are used in quantitative research and are typically seen as objective and conclusive so long as the research is valid and reliable. Statistics can help the group to discuss a problem without deviating into subjective experiences. Qualitative research focuses on exploring a problem and investigating it using in-depth methods such as interviews, focus groups, case study analysis or immersion into the field to experience firsthand what the subjects experience. The data collected is usually analyzed in a subjective manner. Quantitative research is more concerned with testing a hypothesis and identifying variables to see what their relationship is. It collects data that is more objectively analyzed via statistical analysis, such as t-tests or chi-square tests, and this shapes group vs. individual evaluations as well. While it is true that both qualitative and quantitative studies can have hypotheses, the reality is that quantitative…


Sample Source(s) Used

References

Briggs, S., & Helms, L. B. (2015). The practice of American public policymaking. New York: Routlege Taylor & Francis Group.

Reich, R. (Harvard Book Store, Producer). (2010). Robert B. Reich: The next economy and Americla's future. Frontline: Inside the Meltdown Series. [Video] Retrieved from [https://forum-network.org/lectures/robert-b-reich-the-next-economy-and-america-s-future/]

Schaufele, B., McMillian, M. L., Boxall, P. C., Adamowicz, W. L., & Rivera, C. S. (2010). Measuring social preferences in groups versus as individuals: Income inequality aversion using the leaky bucket method. Journal of Applied Economics and Policy, 29(1), 1-1

Cite this Document

Join thousands of other students and "spark your studies."

Sign Up for FREE
Related Documents

Studyspark Study Document

Policy Options for Reducing Youth Involvement in Gangs in Low Income Areas...

Pages: 11 (3165 words) Sources: 7 Subject: Criminal Justice Document: #72138798

POLICY Youth and Gangs in Low Income AreasThis assignment is based on Burgess� concentric model, which divides urban centers into five zones that differ by income levels and distance from the central business district (Allen et al., 2005). Gang activity is more prominent in the �loop� (the CBD), the transition zone, which is characterized by low incomes and slum conditions, and the factory zone, which is dominated by factories and

Studyspark Study Document

Individual Reflection on Team Experience Evolution of

Pages: 10 (3451 words) Sources: 7 Subject: Business - Management Document: #51889307

Individual Reflection on Team Experience Evolution of the group/team over the term Group/team dynamics Group structure Intergroup/intra-group conflict According to Robert Harris, (2009) decision making is the process or the study of identifying and choosing the best alternatives and best fits the goals, values and the desired outcome. He further adds that it's a process of sufficiently reducing uncertainty and doubt about alternatives to allow a reasonable choice to be made from among them. It is

Studyspark Study Document

Policy Reform to Promote the

Pages: 26 (7175 words) Sources: 5 Subject: Teaching Document: #67566472

In other, more charter-friendly states, there are multiple authorizers -- universities, state boards, even specially created bodies with expertise in charter school creation. The new bill before the state House and Senate will give the Board of Education an advising role on charter school applications prior to going before the local school board. Patrick Henry School of Science and Arts opened Aug. 11, 2010 making it the 10th charter school

Studyspark Study Document

Counseling Groups Give Members the

Pages: 30 (9035 words) Sources: 25 Subject: Psychology Document: #57245828

" This involves coming up with a list of the consequences of reacting to an event (Budman, 1992). This means that they describe what emotions the activating event made them feel. The principles facilitate being rational because they shift focus from emotions to logic. The group gets an opportunity to look at the problems they face from a rational perspective, which creates room for possibilities. Thinking rationally helps in creating many

Studyspark Study Document

Public Policy-Making: Public School Funding

Pages: 15 (4206 words) Sources: 5 Subject: Teaching Document: #53478876

The trial lasted seven months and Justice Leland Degrasse rendered his decision, 719 N.Y.S.2d 475 on January 10, 2001, in favor of plaintiffs and ordered the state to ensure that all public schools provide the opportunity for a sound basic education to their students." (Hunter, 2004) Entered, as part of this decision was a "costing-out study as the threshold task in developing a new school funding system." (Hunter, 2004)

Studyspark Study Document

Systematic Review of Effectiveness of Group-Based Antenatal Education Programs...

Pages: 67 (18363 words) Sources: 100 Subject: Teaching Document: #73902472

Antenatal Education Systematic Review Antenatal education programms In pregnant women, how does group antenatal education compare to no antenatal education or individual antenatal education for improving outcomes of childbirth and parenting? In pregnant women, how does group antenatal education compare to no antenatal education or individual antenatal education for improving outcomes of childbirth and parenting? Antenatal education programs are key in improving maternal health all over the world. They have been widely embraced in

Join thousands of other students and

"spark your studies".