Study Document

Democracy in America in the 21st Century Essay

Pages:7 (2223 words)

Sources:5

Subject:Government

Topic:Democracy

Document Type:Essay

Document:#23576697


“Where Do We Go From Here?”

Democracy was meant to be government by the rule of the people. Athens is most famous for being the ancient city-state to represent democratic government and in a way the city-state was best situated for democracy: the people were educated and keen on performing their civic duty—at least for a generation or two. By the time the playwright Aristophanes came along, some Athenians were shirking their civic duty to the extent that the satirist penned his most attack on Athenian complacency. The point is that democracy is only as effective as the people within the community are at performing their civic duty. When the very concept of civic-mindedness is lost or when the community becomes so large that it is impossible for people to govern directly, the concept of democracy can become a screen hiding a much more nefarious system of power like what is seen today, where various organs of the state operate unseen and through unelected (i.e., appointed) officials who control the strings of government and have their pockets padded by insiders and lobbyists of various big businesses. Democracy is the buzzword of many an authoritarian government the world over today, yet democracy is hardly seen in reality. Both Mansbridge and Dahl talk about a free market system—and Friedman essentially advocates for this because it is a system in which capital best thrives—but the reality of the world today is that the markets are not free, interventionism has run amok, and the world is now living under a global command economy whose terms are dictated by a triumvirate of central banks, government leaders and big business owners. Everyone else is simply told what to do and expected to like, and one should need no more example of this fact than that latest bailout of corporations and hedge funds across the board this April, with the pretense for this corporate bailout being COVID 19. The challenge facing democracy in the world today is the threat of authoritarianism that looms over government via the integration of central banking, organs of the state and big business circumventing the will of power and the democratic means of control.

Authoritarianism was always a problem for democracy, even in Athenian society, because democracy ultimately is an idealistic form of government that tends toward entropy rather than towards stability or control. There are always going to be and there have always been individuals and organizations seeking to exploit imbalances within systems, and democracy as a form of government is not without its limitations. In America, the conflict between democracy as a form of government (best exercised at the local level—i.e., at the state level) and authoritarianism or centralized power emerged at the beginning days of the nation. The debate was between the Federalists (who called for central power in the form of a federal government) and the Anti-Federalists (who called for autonomous governments among each and every state). The Federalists won the day and the centralized government, which started off small, grew over the decades and centuries into a behemoth of a machine with multiple organs now influencing various sectors unseen by most people. The Civil War occurred before a century of this system had even concluded, and the cause was the same—tension between state (local, democratic government) and federal (centralized government). Again, the federal power won out.

There are some examples of states still exercising independent systems of government at the local level—for instance, in terms of legalizing cannabis in numerous states even though it is still considered a schedule one narcotic by the federal government, or in terms of states like California designating sanctuary cities to the chagrin of the federal administration in power—but these instances are small in the much larger scheme of things. Today’s world is governed by central banks, organs of state that persist from one administration to the next, and big business. Any hope for democracy essentially died in the 19th century—but really it was dead from the get-go and Jefferson knew as he was the one who predicted a tyranny of the Judiciary should the Federalists get their way in shaping the constitution of the nation.

In fact, the limitations of democracy should be all too apparent at this point to anyone who has purportedly lived in one. As David Runciman notes, “The history of…

Some parts of this document are missing

Click here to view full document

…own R&D and product development, leading to the crashing of two of its 737-Max planes and the killing of hundreds. The way today’s centralized planners react to loss of life, one would think they would have immediately grounded all planes everywhere in the world until they figured out exactly why those planes crashed—but they did not. They only halt the economy to a standstill when it benefits the principals and their agents—companies like Boeing and Blackrock.

After all, those are the nations of the world today. There is no America. There is only Boeing, Exxon, Amazon, Facebook, Google, Netflix, Apple and a handful of others. They are the nations of the world today. On the 4th of July, everyone should do his civic duty and purchase shares in Apple or Alphabet. Milton Friedman said it best though he understated it to an order of magnitude: “Economic arrangements play a dual role in the promotion of a free society” (8). These arrangements are not determined by the average yokel who votes maybe once every six or seven years. These arrangements are made by the principals and agents of business. “Free society” is essentially something of a canard as well, but all things relative one could argue that Americans are freer than, say, Chinese. But in short order, one will find it hard to distinguish between the two societies, especially if people like Bill Gates get their way and digi-tracking of all people becomes the new means of monitoring one’s “social credit” score.

In conclusion, democracy in America was dead on arrival. Tocqueville saw a world that was significantly different from the world today—but even he noticed that America was a strange hybrid of forces and ideals that defied imagination and that would undoubtedly change and lead to a number of problematic outcomes in the near future. There are those who believe in democracy—in the ideal—and they are enthused and inspired by the steps the Founding Fathers took to create this nation. However, there are also those who take a skeptical stance and see the Founding Fathers as barons of industry, couching their land and power grabs in terms that speak to equity and fairness…


Sample Source(s) Used

Works Cited

Dahl, Robert. On Democracy.

Ferejohn, John. Is Inequality a Threat to Democracy?

Friedman, Milton. Capitalism and Freedom. University of Chicago Press.

Mansbridge, Jane. On the Importance of Getting Things Done. PS, 2012.

Runciman, David. The Confidence Trap. Princeton University Press.

Cite this Document

Join thousands of other students and "spark your studies."

Sign Up for FREE
Related Documents

Study Document

21st Century Education

Pages: 4 (1086 words) Sources: 3 Subject: Black Studies - Philosophy Document: #19720699

Philosophy and Education 21st Century Behavior and trends within the education system are rudimentarily based upon the collective groups collective philosophy. The knowledge base that is infused with ethics combines to create a philosophy that is summarily applied within the classroom. From this aspect, it is clear that all a teacher does is based upon an adopted philosophy that he or she has learned or accepted over the course of time.

Study Document

Theorist Who Offers the Most Useful Insights for 21st Century Warfare...

Pages: 4 (1486 words) Sources: 4 Subject: Military Document: #52380625

theorists from the H100 block of ILE have provided valuable insights on warfare. They range from Clausewitz to Machiavelli to Moltke. Although 200 years have passed since the times of Antoine-Henri Jomini, his theories, principles, and insights are still being used in a twenty-first century warfare. Jomini's principles of war provide linkages to today's doctrine making them still useful today. In order for a theorist of the past to offer

Study Document

America, Without Doubt the Most Powerful Nation

Pages: 4 (1349 words) Sources: 1+ Subject: Government Document: #34152758

America, without doubt the most powerful nation on earth and the sole super-power of the 21st century evokes vastly conflicting feelings in people around the world, depending on their individual paradigm: the lens through which they look at the world. While to most people, America is a symbol of prosperity, freedom and equal opportunity it also is a source of equally negative feelings for others who resent its prosperity, and

Study Document

21st Amendment and Its Impact

Pages: 6 (1727 words) Sources: 1+ Subject: American History Document: #15865460

S. Constitution began yet another short-lived experiment with prohibition, only this time it was on a national level. When it went into effect in January 1920, efforts to repeal the 18th Amendment began almost immediately. In a whirlwind of legislative activity, the 21st Amendment was ratified by the requisite number of states in record time. In their haste to repeal the 18th Amendment, though, lawmakers failed to consider the impact

Study Document

Democracy in the United States What Type

Pages: 5 (1730 words) Sources: 1+ Subject: Government Document: #39572618

Democracy in the United States [...] what type of democracy is the U.S. What are the most democratic and least democratic features of American national government? Do you believe that the U.S. presently embodies the core values of a democracy or do you believe that the U.S. has yet to attain the essence of democratic ideals? Democracy is one of the most sought after forms of government, and some

Study Document

Do We Have a Democracy

Pages: 2 (642 words) Sources: 1+ Subject: Government Document: #81608729

21st Century American 'Democracy': The Best Government that Money Can Buy Within polarized, interest group-dominated 21st century United States life, most Americans still cling to the idea, despite abundant evidence to the contrary, that we live in a democracy. In today's America, however, that idea is more quaint than accurate. Instead, as the article suggests, America is more a pseudo-democracy than a real one, in which special interest groups (and, as

Join thousands of other students and

"spark your studies".